Skip to main content

Toni Nadal offers solutions to scheduling in tennis: "Super tiebreak instead of a fifth set?"

Rafael Nadal's uncle and former coach is open to eliminating the five-set format in Grand Slams and proposes four alternatives to avoid matches that end in the early morning hours. 

Toni Nadal proposes eliminating the fifth set. Photo: gettyimages

Toni Nadal is a deep connoisseur of tennis and has long warned of the need for changes, being dissatisfied with the evolution of the sport. The legendary coach of Rafael Nadal considers it essential to avoid matches ending in the early hours of the morning, emphasizing the need for decisions that improve this issue of schedule in tennis and proposing four innovations.

This is not the first time that Toni Nadal has surprised with groundbreaking proposals for the future of tennis. Just this week, he suggested reducing the size of rackets, in a reflection that has sparked considerable controversy, but not as much as the solutions provided in a column for ElPais to avoid having so many matches in a season that end in the early hours of the morning.

The match between Shelton and Alcaraz at the US Open has ignited discussions about how detrimental it is for players, fans, and the entire ecosystem of this sport to see a match finish at 3:30 am, something that is not an isolated incident as there are situations throughout the year where matches end after midnight.

Remote video URL

These are Toni Nadal's proposals to solve the schedule problem in tennis

Uncle Toni has wanted to share his thoughts on the matter, being open to eliminating five sets in Grand Slams for men, something that is considered a fundamental part of the essence of tennis, as he himself acknowledges in his writing.

"I think it is urgent to make some changes and review the schedules if we want to not jeopardize the well-being of the players," he warns, being aware that this may go against the economic interests that drive the world of tennis. Toni proposes several interesting and quite groundbreaking solutions.

Play the quarter-finals on two different courts

This is something that Wimbledon does and that, in some editions, Roland Garros has also put into practice. It makes sense from the perspective that all the quarter-finals are played on the same day, but by holding two matches simultaneously, fans lose the chance to enjoy all four encounters of the penultimate round.

Advance the start time of each day

Most tournaments have a night session which, in the case of the US Open, starts at 7:00 PM and has two matches scheduled. A possible solution to "mitigate the problem," as Toni says, would be to advance the start time of both sessions, in order to gain time and avoid such a late end to the day if the matches are lengthy.

Reduce playing time

This is where Toni Nadal really takes a stand, being aware that he is challenging one of the core principles in the history of tennis. Many consider the five sets in Grand Slam tournaments for men non-negotiable, but not the Balearic.

"Playing matches best of three sets like in women's tennis? Clearly, it would be a good alternative, but it would conflict with the essence and tradition of the Grand Slams," notes a Toni whose open-mindedness to this idea is quite surprising.

However, the Balearic is aware of how much this measure could distort the history of tennis, which is why he proposes an alternative solution, such as eliminating the fifth set to play a super tiebreak when the score is tied at two sets each.

It feels like tennis is at a very important moment in defining itself for the future, navigating between fidelity to history, the magic of the epic that the five sets provide, and the apparent (though not necessarily real) need to reduce times and be a more dynamic and "consumable" sport for new generations. Toni Nadal's stance has surprised many. What do you think?

This is an automatic translation. You can read the original news, Toni Nadal da soluciones a los horarios en el tenis: "¿Supertiebreak en lugar de un quinto set?"